The study of soil
microbiology as it relates to forensic science is a relatively novel idea.
While DNA, dental records, and trace evidence has been used to determine identities
of both suspects and victims, along with location of crime scene and other
details, soil could potentially be used to determine if a victim was placed in
a location then removed. By studying the microbial composition of soils around
a decomposing body, scientists will be able to track the fluctuations and
changes of microbes from the soil. Using this data, it could be determined how
old a dump site location is, or if someone reported a dump site, this data
could support or disprove such claims.
First, it is important
that scientists understand the basics of normal soil microbiology. Soil microbiology
was once studied by sampling soil sites and simply counting microbes from the
samples [1]. This was not sufficient enough to develop a better understanding
of the microbial composition of the soil.
Since these methods were not efficient enough, soil enzymes were
studied. Because the presence of enzymes in the soil is indicative of the
presence of microbes, it is important to study the enzymes that are found. By studying
these enzymes, and through the knowledge of microbiology, scientists are able
to link the enzymes with certain bacteria that undergo various enzymatic activities
in order to survive in the soil [1].
Enzyme testing is not without
its faults, however. Simply using the enzymes found in the soil and a
background of microbiology will not show, for certain, which microbes can be
classified as being present in the soil [1]. Instead of using enzymatic testing
as confirmatory and characterizing tests, scientists will use the data gathered
from these methods to monitor various details of the soil. Various approaches
to testing soil have been proposed over the years in efforts to more clearly
classify the microbiota of soil. Through enzymatic testing and metabolic
analysis, the compositions of soils are better understood than they were fifty
years ago, but the complete classification is still out of grasp.
Even more recently
developed, DNA sequencing of soil samples has proven to be a relatively well
informative method for determining what, and just how many, microbes compose
the soil. While there are several methods which are currently used to study the
DNA or RNA of soil microbiology, several in the science community have
supported the ideas that molecular ecology is essential for the study of soil
microbiology [1]. The future of understanding the microbiology of soil is still
geared towards the continued study of microbial composition and activities
through the use of molecular techniques [1]. Due to the vast contrast between the
many soil types, along with the added complexities from climate, altitude, and geographic
location, the complete composition of soil microbiota may never be absolutely
determined. Along with all these complicating factors, the changes that are
constantly taking place in these factors will continue to keep the soil
microbiology from being completely determined.
By knowing the basics
of soil microbiology, scientists should one day be able to more widely apply
what is known in order to utilize soil from forensic cases to determine a
variety of evidentiary information. Through the knowledge of general soil
characteristics, scientists can already begin to study forensic applications
for this information in efforts to utilize another route of evidence to help solve
crimes. Because we already see widespread changes in crime scenes from the more
well known aspects of crime investigation due to television, perhaps developing
new techniques to uncovering clues will prove to be beneficial not only to the
scientific community, but the criminal justice community as well.
Resources:
1. Insam, H. (2001). Developments in soil microbiology since the mid 1960s. Geoderma, 100,
389-402.
This is interesting to me because I am a Forensic Chemistry major with Biology and CJ minors.
ReplyDeleteI do agree that this field of science has already started to be, and will continue to be, a major component to crime scenes involved with outdoor locations.
Scientists were already able to tell small things about soil from crime scenes; such as, different types of soils found in places that were not their native area shows movement of the body. Now, with this new research using microbes, the prosecution will have a stronger case against the suspect due to the more intricate details given by this study, further narrowing down the possibilities and doubts.
Studies like this goes to show that forensics is ever evolving and getting better hopefully decreasing people's willingness to commit a crime knowing the possibility to get caught is getting higher daily.
Wow! this is amazing. I honestly had no idea there was such a study where one can find out details of a crime scene. Though I'm just curious, how can one tell how long a body has been decomposing? I know you mentioned microbes in the soil but I wonder what methods are used to acquire that info.
ReplyDeleteWell, that's what we're trying to figure out. Most of my blogs will probably tie into all of this, so maybe we'll be able to see the progression of such studies. The aim in this sort of research is more so to discover a dump site or crime scene where no body is present. If the body is present, there is a lot more information out there regarding the human microbiome during decomposition that could be utilized in determining how far decomp has progressed. With the soil studies, we are trying to determine the evolution and shifts between bacterial communities in an effort to see if it is even possible to determine this sort of information. As far as molecular techniques in testing the microbial composition, PCR and pyrosequencing are popular methods to identify the microbes.
DeleteMetagenomic approaches can only become better as studies add metagenomes to databases. I, for one, am looking forward to the development of methods that compare samples of metagenomes to look for bioindicator genes and species.
ReplyDelete